New DevelopmentWorld of Elliman

FIND YOUR FAVORITE PLACE TO BE

We are experts in the luxury rental market.

Port Jefferson

Luxury listings for rent in Port Jefferson

18 of 18 Homes
COMPARE

$2,500

/ Month

415 Myrtle Ave, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA1,000 sf
DE Master Logo
douglas elliman exclusive

$4,350

/ Month

907 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY

3,400 sf

Listing Courtesy of SIGNATURE PREMIER PROPERTIES., MICHELE N. SANCHEZ CBR - 631-312-7862

$3,700

/ Month

210 Michigan Ave, Port Jefferson, NY

3 br2 BA, 1 HALF BA1,500 sf

Listing Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES., KATHLEEN COUGHLAN CBR - 516-318-1706

$3,320

/ Month

44 Pinnacle Dr 44, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br2 BA1,169 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$3,320

/ Month

1 Pinnacle Dr 2, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br2 BA1,169 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$3,215

/ Month

655 Belle Terre Rd 78, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA690 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$3,215

/ Month

655 Belle Terre Rd 21, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA690 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

Coming soon | NEW

$3,100

/ Month

202 Main St #210, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA944 sf

Listing Courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER AMERICAN HOMES., DANIELLE MORGENBESSER - 631-786-5649

$3,095

/ Month

64 Pinnacle Dr 64, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br2 BA1,096 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$3,095

/ Month

54 Pinnacle Dr 54, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br2 BA1,096 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,920

/ Month

1-2B Dark Hollow Rd 1-2B, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA790 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,920

/ Month

7-2B Dark Hollow Rd 7-2B, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA790 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,920

/ Month

6-2A Dark Hollow Rd 6-2A, Port Jefferson, NY

2 br1 BA790 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,725

/ Month

655 Belle Terre Rd 7, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br1 BA560 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,725

/ Month

655 Belle Terre Rd 35, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br1 BA560 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,725

/ Month

655 Belle Terre Rd 29, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br1 BA560 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

$2,700

/ Month

126 E Main St B, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br1 BA633 sf

Listing Courtesy of MICHAEL ALEXANDER PROPERTIES., MICHAEL A. OMEDES - 631-767-7962

$2,460

/ Month

3 President+ Rd 3-4B, Port Jefferson, NY

1 br1 BA657 sf

Listing Courtesy of FAIRFIELD PROPERTIES., MICHELLE HOLMES - 631-499-6694

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the OneKey® MLS. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor the website owner shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Property locations as displayed on any map are best approximations only and exact locations should be independently verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers personal non-commercial use and it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

©2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.

LAST UPDATE DATE On SEP 18 2026 AT 11:53 PM COORDINATED UNIVERSAL TIME (UTC).