23 Old Montauk Hwy

Wake up to the rhythm of a true Amagansett morning. Walk or bike to Atlantic Avenue and Indian Wells Beach, pick up fresh pastries and local produce, then spend the afternoon exploring the village's charming boutiques, cafés, and celebrated restaurants.

Beautifully built by the renowned Forst Construction, this exceptional traditional home blends timeless Hamptons craftsmanship with modern luxury. Offering 5 bedrooms, 5.5 bathrooms, a thoughtfully designed floor plan spans three finished levels, including a beautifully finished lower level ideal for entertaining or additional living space.

Designed for effortless indoor-outdoor living, the home features expansive decks and balconies overlooking the backyard, while the 50-foot heated gunite pool creates a true resort-style setting for summer enjoyment. A two-car attached garage, quality finishes, and classic architectural details complete this elegant retreat.

The nearby Long Island Rail Road station and Hampton Jitney stop make weekend arrivals from Manhattan effortless, allowing guests to leave the car behind and embrace the relaxed pace that defines Amagansett.

This is more than a summer rental. It's an opportunity to experience Amagansett the way locals have treasured it for generations, where mornings begin with ocean air, afternoons are spent between the beach and the farm stands, and every sunset reminds you why this special corner of the Hamptons continues to captivate year after year.