Shelter Island Heights | Luxury Homes for Rent & Real Estate

Fireplace, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Sun Room

Bedroom, Interior, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting

Fitness Equipment, Interior, Recessed Lighting

starting at

$35,000

/ Jun

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

5 br5 ba, 1 half ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Living room, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Recessed Lighting

Bathroom, Bedroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Recessed Lighting

Attached, Backyard, Exterior, Facade, Split Level

starting at

$22,000

/ Jun

13 Dinah Rock Rd, Shelter Island, NY

4 br3 ba, 1 half ba2,800 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Tile Countertops, Wood Texture Flooring

starting at

$18,000

/ Jun

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY

3 br3 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Stone Walls, Water

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Stone Walls, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Stone Walls

Bedroom, Interior, Wooden Beams, Wood Texture Flooring

Home Office, Interior, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Backyard, Exterior, Facade, Brick Facade, French Provincial

starting at

$50,000

/ Jul

28 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY

3 br3 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances

$40,000

/ Month

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY

5 br5 ba, 1 half ba4,000 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Glass Shower, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Glass Shower, Interior

Home Office, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Interior, Piano, Wood Texture Flooring

Billiard Table, Game Room, Interior, Recessed Lighting

Fitness Equipment, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Attached, Backyard, Exterior, Facade, Farmhouse

starting at

$30,000

/ Jun

43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY

5 br6 ba, 1 half ba5,375 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

new

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Wood Texture Flooring

starting at

$5,000

/ Ext Season

5 Mimosa Pl, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba1,604 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Dining room, Interior, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

$13,000

/ Short-term

80 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba1,755 sf

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Stainless Steel Appliances

Dining room, Interior, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Glass Shower, Interior, Utility Closets, Washer

$12,000

/ Short-term

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY

2 br2 ba

douglas elliman exclusive

Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Dining room, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Chandelier, Fireplace, Interior, Living room

Chandelier, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Chandelier, Home Office, Interior, Wood Texture Flooring

Attached, Exterior, Facade, Queen Anne Victorian

$7,000

/ Short-term

11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY

4 br2 ba, 1 half ba

douglas elliman exclusive

price reduced

Exterior, Facade, Lake, Queen Anne Victorian

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Pendant Lights, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Fireplace, Interior, Kitchen, Pendant Lights, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Fireplace, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Bathroom, Dual Sink Vanities, Free Standing Baths, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Interior, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Bedroom, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Water, Wood Texture Flooring

Home Office, Interior, Recessed Lighting, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Living room, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

Dining room, Interior, Kitchen, Recessed Lighting, Stainless Steel Appliances, Wood Texture Flooring

$75,000

/ Month

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY

6 br4 ba, 1 half ba4,600 sf

Listing Courtesy of CORCORAN, MARGOT REUTTER - 631-484-0991

FIND YOUR FAVORITE PLACE TO BE

Luxury listings for rent in Shelter Island Heights

FEATURED IMAGE:

SORT BY

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

13 Dinah Rock Rd, Shelter Island, NY

5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY

28 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY

61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY

43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island, NY

5 Mimosa Pl, Shelter Island, NY

80 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY

11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY

15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY