« Back to Previous Page | Real Estate»Agents»Kristy Naddell

Kristy Naddell

Kristy Naddell
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

10200 Main Road
Mattituck, NY 11952
Office: 631.298.6183
Mobile: 631.905.8584
Fax: 631.298.8133

email me »
download vCard »


I had been looking to buy a place in Greenport NY for about a year. I found available inventory for sale was minimal. My friends suggested Kristy Naddell as they dealt with her under a similar tight inventory situation and Kristy found them a place they've been happy with. Although I was looking for the proverbial "needle in the haystack", Kristy worked diligently reaching out to people to see if they were interested in selling. Within 2 months, after much networking, searching and direct mailers to perspective sellers Kristy called me at 7 am on a Monday morning. A place went on the market overnight, she summoned me to see it right away. We walked inside and within 15 minutes she had a full price offer from me but alerted me that had she was suspicious of the sellers. Apparently she was right, the sellers family were dealing with internal issues. It took 4 months for the deal to close. Kristy wasn't deterred and continued in her search to fine that "needle in the haystack". Shortly thereafter, she had found another place thru her networking that wasn't even listed yet. We inspected it on Sunday morning, revisited it on Tuesday, made an offer which was accepted and we closed within a 3 weeks. Throughout our interactions, Kristy portrayed the traits of a honest, sincere, respectful, diligent, hard working individual. Simply put, Kristy is a no-nonsense business professional I would recommend to any buyer or seller.

Sincerely, John Donaldson

Working with Kristy was amazing! She guided me through the whole process – from making sure the pictures were right all the way until final negotiations. Her knowledge of the market on the North Fork is apparent, and she went above and beyond to ensure the house was well-promoted. I had complete confidence that she was on top of everything. We ended up with not one but FOUR offers – all above asking. This was an emotional time for me as I was selling a house that had been in my family for 4 generations, but having her right by my side helped lessen the pain. And at the final walk-through, we talked so much I didn’t even cry! I had heard that Kristy was excellent, and she absolutely lives up to her reputation. Thank you, Kristy!

K. Schweibert

We had a great experience working with Kristy! She was always professional while being fun to work with at the same time. Selling a home can be stressful but Kristy made it an easy process. Always there when needed but never intrusive. We would highly recommend working with her!

Sue and Al

We met Kristy in the summer of 2016 when my wife and I rented a home in Cutchogue. That fall we ended up buying a home in the same town and Kristy was our broker. Fast forward 2 years, some life changes and yet again Kristy was our broker for the sale of our home.

Since day one, Kristy has always been an absolute pleasure to work with. From renting, to buying and selling, we have experienced all phases with Kristy on our side. She has always listened to us with great patience. Kristy is extremely knowledgeable on the current market and provides a sense of calmness with her demeanor. She is very much in tuned to what buyers and sellers want. Kristy has also become a friend of ours and we highly recommend her!

Kelly and Phil

"Kristy was a most professional and experienced broker. She is hard working, energetic and seeks to find just the right buyer for the property and complete the sale to your satisfaction. Everything in the process from start to finish, was smooth and pleasant. An astute, sharp, active businesswoman will be at your side with advice. My top recommendation!"

S. Lewis

"You will NOT be disappointed if you choose Kristy!!! She was always available to answer our questions & helped make the entire house buying process go very smoothly. We Highly Recommend Kristy to everyone looking for an agent."

-Jim and Kate

"Kristy was wonderful. She was patient and helped us find the perfect house that fit our family's needs. She is professional, knowledgeable and negotiated a fair price for our new home. She kept us updated during the entire process. We feel very lucky to have found her. She is a true GEM."

Nancy Rojas

"It was a pleasure working with Kristy, she was knowledgeable about the area we were looking in and made sure we got all the amenities we asked for in a home. Kristy made the experience very easy and helped us through the entire process of buying a home. The referrals she gave us from a real estate attorney to vendors in the area was a gigantic help. She is an outstanding realtor and now a new friend. Thank you Kristy for helping us find and buy our dream home!"

Joseph R

"We cannot thank Kristy enough for going above and beyond. She managed to find us a mortgage company which met our needs, was basically on call whenever we asked to see the property and did a ton of research for us. After the same was completed, she provided us with a wealth of information (neatly categorized) from things to do in the area (as we were not familiar with the area) as well as vendors and contractors. I would not hesitate to do business with Kristy in the future or to recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home."

Teresa and Brian

Kristy was a great asset to have for an agent. Her tenacious sales skills and her deep local knowledge of the North Fork had my confidence from day one. She brought in qualified buyers, always kept me well informed and found a good match within my expectations. We encountered a number bumps along the way, but she never called me with an issue without having a possible solution. A difficult job well done.

-Mr. Shea

"We found Kristy on Zillow as a result of her deservedly high rating. After interviewing her along with several other agents, we knew she was the right fit for us. Kristy worked aggressively to find us a great house. She is knowledgeable about the North Fork market and well-networked in the area. She is always responsive by phone, email and text, and answered every question and concern during the process. All of her recommendations for other vendors in the area--inspector, insurance agent, contractor--were fantastic to work with, as well. We would not hesitate to work with Kristy again or to recommend her to anyone serious about buying on the North Fork."

-Alex and Jordan

"We had an amazing experience working with Kristy. We found Kristy by chance through Zillow when we wanted to get into a house very quickly that we saw listed for sale on Zillow. Kristy met us the next day and educated us on the area as well as the market we were looking in. Kristy worked very hard to learn what we liked and didn't like and showed us appropriate houses in our budget. When we finally found the house we loved, Kristy helped us get over the finish line, she was in constant contact through the offer process and provided relevant and helpful advice on how to best position our offer. After some tough negotiations on her part, our offer was accepted. Kristy worked hard to get everything needed to all parties so we could close quickly (within a month of signing contracts). Kristy is very knowledgeable, diligent and easy to work with. I highly recommend her for any deal on the Northfork!"

Cathy and Jay

I had a great experience with Kristy Nadell. My husband and I worked with Kristy for about 10 months to find a home for our family on the North Fork. She is very knowledgeable about the different towns and neighborhoods and very responsive whenever we called, texted or emailed her with questions. She is warm and caring and always has a smile on her face. We plan to call her for our next house, too! Thank you Kristy!

Kevin and Brigid

I had a great experience with Kristy Nadell. My husband and I worked with Kristy for about 10 months to find a home for our family on the North Fork. She is very knowledgeable about the different towns and neighborhoods and very responsive whenever we called, texted or emailed her with questions. She is warm and caring and always has a smile on her face. We plan to call her for our next house, too! Thank you Kristy!

Kevin and Brigid

Kristy was wonderful to work with. She is a consummate professional and a great person who brings a wealth of knowledge, strong negotiation skills, and a very personable bearing to her work. She is incredibly responsive, hard-working, tenacious, and honest, all of which make her a pleasure to work with. Having dealt with numerous real estate brokers in the past, I find her exceptional in a profession that one often finds wanting

Bim and Alexie

I had the best experience with Kristy as my agent. I wouldn't even say agent, I'd say advocate! She worked so hard to help me with my buying of my home. Kristy goes above and beyond what I've ever experienced! My sellers were challenging (to put it politely), and Kristy was in constant communication with the seller’s agent to advocate for my best interest and get me my dream summer/weekend home! I've worked with other agents and I've bought and sold multiple properties and I'd say that from my past experiences, I've never had someone work harder for me to get the deal done and keep my interests in mind. Kristy knows the north fork area. She knew exactly what I was looking for and listened to what my wants and must haves were. Kristy is also a very calming person and took away so much of the worry in the negotiations and the contracts. She just handles so much for you! I couldn't be at the inspection because the house is far from my primary residence and I had to be out of the country that week for work, Kristy took care of it and text me constantly thru it all! In all my properties, I've never had an agent tell me to not worry and that they'll handle it for me! Amazing experience with Kristy!! And I do highly recommend her!

T. Joseph

Kristy was the listing agent when we sold our weekend property in Cutchogue last year. She did such a great job, that when it became time to downsize our home in Stony Brook we asked her to co-list our home with our local agent from Douglas Elliman (Marilyn Rubinfeld). They were the perfect pair, our home was expertly marketed, we got great guidance in the negotiating process and their follow up was seamless. We successfully sold our home above listing price after considering multiple offers

Jim and Nancy Joy

It had been almost 30-years since I had to got through the drudge of finding a home, getting mortgage, etc. Some people 'jokingly' said to me "never trust a Real Estate Agent," while I was going through this process; not true with Kristy Naddell.

Kristy Naddell was actually the Listing Agent for the seller. After first meeting Kristy I quickly realized that her willingness to help both the seller and the buyer go through a smooth transition was what made this experience something to cherish. She answered any questions I had via text, email or phone calls with speed and accuracy. She was very patient with me, and I never felt afraid to ask what some might consider a stupid question. Kristy Naddell is in her element working in this profession and an asset for the both buyers and sellers. .

Michael M

We highly recommend Kristy and would definitely work with her again! We fell for a tricky house in Greenport, that required many consultations from contractors, and Kristy remained encouraging, patient and positive throughout the entire process. We always felt we were in expert hands. In addition to her impressive knowledge of the North Fork, she is a pleasure to work with. It's clear she loves what she does and is always willing to go the extra mile for a client. She even let us interrupt her Easter holiday when we needed a last-minute inspection. You couldn't ask for more from an agent!

Claudia and Alex

Kristy was helpful, informative and responsive. She knew the neighborhoods and the homes well. She was able to get the seller to negotiate and get a better deal. I highly recommend her.

Alice and Rich

"We are happy to recommend Kristy Nadell as a real estate agent in the North Fork. Helping us to navigate a relatively complex transaction, Kristy struck the right balance of working incredibly hard for us, yet not being pushy or overly aggressive. Kristy provided the comps and local real estate knowledge that helped make us comfortable with the negotiation and eventual transaction. After a closing, many salespeople we have worked with in the past, move on to the next deal. Not so with Kristy, who has been an incredible recourse and has helped make our "new summer home" experience in the Norh Fork an enjoyable one! We are delighted to recommend Kristy and look forward to both utilizing her services and referring her to our friends in the future!"

Jimmy and Amy Frank

We had an amazing experience with Kristy. My husband and I were first time homebuyers and Kristy gave us the guidance we needed. We never felt pressure or any insincerity from her recommendations. She's honest and just wants the best for her clients. We loved how responsive she is and quick to get a us answers. Kristy kept us informed the whole time and worked at our pace. We would highly recommend working with her!

Diana & Richie C.

Kristy was exceedingly knowledgeable, kind, diligent, responsive and helpful in guiding our family's purchase of a home on the North Fork. We cannot recommend her highly enough. From the first showing through move in, Kristy provided support, assistance, and optimism. We would happily work with her again, and would suggest that anyone looking to buy or sell on the North Fork give her a call.

Jack and Kathy

My wife and I came to Kristy with a laundry list of needs and wants for our Northfork purchase. Kristy did an excellent job of putting together a list of homes for us to view that fit our needs and after one day of showings, we made an offer and had it accepted the next morning! She was great throughout the process, from start to closing. We closed last week and couldn't be happier! I highly recommend Kristy for all your Real Estate needs

Kristy is extremely knowledgeable about the North Fork and the process of buying a home. She was very patient and responsive throughout the entire process. I highly recommend Kristy for anyone looking in the area. She is a true asset to Douglas Elliman. Thank you for your help!

Kelly and Phil

Kirsty recently sold a property for me in Mattituck, NY. This wasn't an easy job because this property was handed down through an estate to 9 people, including myself. Many of us hadn't even spoken to each other in over 40+ years! The property was in such disrepair and the fact that she had to coordinate showings to prospective buyers with the tenants who were living on the property, made this less than an ideal situation. But she handled it all professionally and successfully! If it wasn't for her commitment, I don't think this property would have ever sold. She was always available to me, no matter the day or time, and I will always be thankful to her for that.

M. Resner

Kristy was very warm and welcoming from the moment we met her. She knew a lot about the neighborhood and was very helpful getting us acclimated to Mattituck. We would recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy or rent a home on the North Fork.

Sheila and Joel

The truth is the marketing of our churches represent a real challenge to anyone attempting to sell them...such as...being sensitive to the emotional impact of the community when an historic church closes then working to bring sincere buyers forward that can envision what the next use of the church properties could be... we in the church couldn't be happier with the effort that Kristy Naddell has brought forth... we see her as a true professional... who uses all the technological resources available to bring a diverse range of perspective buyers to see our properties

Pastor Tom McLeod

We interviewed a few brokers including Kristy, whose name came to us from another broker. She came to our first meeting totally prepared having done her homework on our property and the market. She presented a multi-tiered marketing plan to support the pricing strategy she was proposing in a confident manner which gave us great comfort in our selection of her as our broker.

The layers of her marketing plan included offering great guidance on home staging, high quality professional photography (including drone aerials), extensive social media, print ads, multiple open houses and leveraging the MLS network. Now here is the important part... it wasn't smoke and mirrors, she did every bit of what she said she would do.

Beyond the marketing process Kristy was equally helpful, confident and responsive as we navigated through negotiations and the closing process. She was in contact frequently and we always felt well informed and well advised.

In the end we were thrilled with our choice of Kristy as our broker and would highly recommend her to future clients.

Jim & Nancy Joy

Kristy was a wonderful to work with. Flexible, knowledgable and attentive. My sister and I were first time home buyers and she eased our nerves and made sure everything went smoothly. A true pro and professional.

Carolyn and Patty Ornst

Kristy is an easy-going, fun person to work with. Her knowledge of the North Fork property market and genuine interest in our needs and desires made buying our property a fantastic experience. She possesses all the attributes necessary to be an excellent broker: she knows her market very extremely well, she is diligent, responsive and above all patient with her clients. She clearly takes pride in doing a good job. Kristy was extremely attentive, and offered sound advice during the entire process. We couldn't be happier with our investment or with the service we received from her. We would certainly recommend Kristy Naddell to others!

Cindy Wickham

My wife and I randomly reached out to Kristy on one of her listings and have been working with her for over the past 3 months looking for a house in the Greenport area, which seems to be a very tough buyer market right now. Good houses seem to get bought up very quickly. But throughout the process, we have made offers on 5 different houses, each of which didn’t work out for one reason or another. Three houses we couldn’t come to an agreement on, and we had two houses that we made an agreement on which fell through due to reasons beyond our control (1 owner didn’t want to close for 4 months, the other house we decided was too overpriced). So we are still looking…. And in addition to this purchase, we have been through the process of purchasing a house a few times before, with our principal residence and a vacation property in NJ, but working with Kristy has been the best experience by far we have had yet. And as far as what has made this our best experience (even though we haven’t successfully bought a house yet) is as follows: 1) Kristy is extremely knowledgeable about the areas and market overall, across the north fork. She gives us an honest and expert opinion about the houses we are looking at, even when it may not be exactly what we want to hear. She is not like other agents we have dealt with that just tell you what you want to hear so that they can try to make a sale. She has been working hard to understand what we are looking for (even when we are sometimes not sure) and has been working to help us find it. For example, we were close to moving forward on a house in East Marion which we were on the fence about, and when we told her we had a feeling we may be overpaying, she agreed explaining that is why the house has been on the market so long and suggested we keep looking for something better. 2) Kristy is also very organized, always on time and always works to accommodate our schedule. This is pretty important for us, being that we travel such a long distance to get out there. She has set up a few separate days in which we looked at 10 or 12 houses and we zipped through them on such a smooth schedule, arranging for the listing agents to be at the house to meet with us. She even arranged for one of her local pool contacts to be at a house we were thinking of making an offer on to give us an estimate on installing a pool. 3) She is always responsive by phone, email or text. There have been numerous times that we have reached out to Kristy on off hours with questions, concerns, thoughts or just new houses we find and want to see and she is extremely responsive. There has never been a time where we have been left sitting around wondering if we will hear back from her. And being as impatient as we can be, that has been very helpful in getting us through this sometimes stressful process. All in all, Kristy has been a great agent and we wouldn’t use anyone else to represent us on this purchase, or any future purchases/sales we look to make.

Roger & Maria

Working with Kristy was a delight! We weren't really certain what we were looking for in the beginning of our search and Kristy was patient and flexible, giving us varying options, so that we could not only figure out what we wanted, but find the perfect fit for us in the end! Thanks, Kristy!

Josh N.

Kristy recently guided us in purchasing a home on the North Fork. She really listened to understand what the family was looking for an her local knowledge was second to none. I would certainly recommend Kristy for anyone looking in the area.

-Matt P

Kristy is a wonderful broker. She is friendly, knowledgeable and very hard working. When showing me properties, she was very honest - it was clear that she had my best interests in mind at all times. She is also a very strong negotiator, getting me a price and leading a negotiation strategy that proved to be very effective. And she knew the area extremely well.

I would highly recommend Kristy to any buyer or seller on the North Fork or the Hampton’s!

-M Harley

My experience with Kristy was excellent. I needed to fine two place out east this year both very specific in nature, different from each other and in was needed in a short period of time, In both cases the first options she recommended were perfect. I took them both and the process was easy and quick, with no surprises. Enjoyable and couldn't recommend her more highly.

-S Rosenberg

I've done numerous house searches and property sales over the past 25 years because my job often requires me to relocate, and Kristy Naddell is one of the best, most professional real estate agents I've ever worked with. She has a terrific grasp of the area and executing transactions. She is proactive about keeping me informed of new listings and changes in the market. She's fantastic about returning calls, scheduling viewings and answering even the most complicated questions. She also has a terrific demeanor and many connections in the business. I'd highly recommend working with her if you're looking to buy or sell a home.


Kristy was really great to work with. She's responsive and always made herself available - her enthusiasm shows she clearly loves what she does. She was thoughtful and honest and we felt she was "on our side" during the whole process. From beginning to end - the "hand holding" and patience with us being first time buyers all the way through a difficult price negotiation and painful closing process - I don't think we could have asked for more. We love our new house. Thanks again Kristy.


Selling a creek front home in this real estate market can be challenging , but the team of Tom Uhlinger and Kristy Naddell , working together with my wife and I, and the support staff and resources of Douglas Elliman, brought our home to market, and completed the sale of our lovely home to a happy and enthusiastic buyer. I highly recommend this team to anyone selling creek front property on the North Fork.

Stephen and Barbara Friedmann

I met Kristy Nadell in November 2013 after a disappointing experience with another broker in town. I didn't actually meet her until a few months later - we spoke over the phone. Kristy made herself available, nights, weekends and was even accessible while on vacation.

This was my first time buying so there were some things I did not know. She was very professional, phoned me regularly with leads of comparable properties and even had some information on properties that "may" be coming on the market.

Working full time, with a family and doing other projects I did not have extra time to waste looking at properties that were not a fit for me. Kristy not only showed us things inside of my parameters I even learned a few things about the area I was looking in.

Long story short (too late I know) Kristy showed me a property in April, got me a good price, Closed on it soon after and I am back at my desk, working, happily, to pay for MY FIRST HOME PURCHASE !!


When I was looking for a good realtor to work with, Kristy was introduced to me by a mutual friend as an expert in real estate. That was fortunately an understatement. She was so extremely professional and took a lot of time to discuss my needs. I was looking to see what opportunities existed in East Hampton for a vacation home, and she showed me a lot of different options. She utilized a lot of technology, including Zillow, in order to demonstrate to me what was available -- and only then did we go and look at properties. This way she made sure only to show me properties that made sense to look at. I would use her again and again, and because I am in the mortgage industry, I have also started referring my clients to her. She's an A+ agent and very highly recommended.

Greg Nouza

"Wow! She responded to my email already!" That is what I exclaimed to my husband after submitting an email inquiry about a house we saw on Zillow. Within minutes Kristy had replied to my email and said she would call me in an hour to discuss a time to meet that afternoon. Well sure enough an hour later she called! We looked at houses that day but did not find the home of our dreams. Not to worry, Kristy was on the case. It took a couple months to find "our" home and through it all Kristy was professional, conscientious and she made it fun! Without a doubt I will use Kristy Naddell for my future real estate needs. She listens, she responds.. the whole customer service thing, she just gets it.-- Mindy Ryan

I am currently working with Ms. Naddell. I am sure we will soon close a deal. She has shown an excellent knowledge of the local real estate market. She listens. By listening she realizes my needs as well as wants in real estate. I am quite confident she will assist me in finding not just any home, but the right one. She is very responsive and a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend her to anyone who values their time and wants to work with a smart and attententive Real Estate professional. 


Joe Bart

My experience with Kristy Naddell was pleasant from start to finish.  Her success is due to her qualities of honesty, patience, perseverance, professionalism, creativity, amiableness, and sincerity.  She can handle all of you real estate needs!

Mrs. Smith

Team Kristy! When my husband and I were looking for a short term rental on the North Fork I knew Kristy was the one to go to. She has an amazing business sense and loves what she does. She was able to send me a few prospects in a timely manner and fit us in on her busy weekend to show us a few places. We were excited to say the least to have found a wonderful rental that Kristy negotiated from start to finish. We know where we're going when we start dabbling in the buyers market. Thanks Kristy for your professional, understanding, and expertise in your field.

The Noppers

Dear Kristy,

Thank you for helping my daughter and I find a rental in Southampton! We appreciate your hard work and honesty in dealing with us and we were very pleased with the selection of properties you found for us. Furthermore, we were very happy with your attentiveness to our needs and for always being available for questions and follow up. We will definitely use you in the future and recommend your services to our friends. Thanks so much!

Angela Goldfarb

Dear Karla,

We would like to let you know how pleased we are with Kristy Naddell. She has worked very hard to show us homes. She is personable, knowledgeable and very professional. She has made our home search a very pleasant experience. Please, convey our appreciation to Kristy. She is a terrific asset to your agency.

Joe and Rhona Vandernoth