226 Main St, Sag Harbor VIllage

Sag Harbor

Half Baths
Single Family Home


Martha Gundersen
Martha Gundersen
  • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
Paul Brennan
Paul Brennan
  • Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker

Property Description

This majestic home sits in the heart Sag Harbor, on the villages famed Captains Row. Built in the 1890s, it has been meticulously renovated and expanded, melding the grandeur of its historic past with the luxurious amenities of today. With an abundance of space for entertaining, work and family life, it offers high ceilings, original wood floors, and huge south-facing windows throughout. An iconic covered porch opens to the foyer, living room, a dining room that seats 12, and a sunny, open great room with wood-burning fireplace and a modern kitchen with top-of-the-line appliances, extra refrigerator drawers and loads of storage. French doors open to a saltwater gunite pool, bluestone terrace, outdoor shower and lush gardens. A private master suite with fireplace overlooks the pool area and gardens. The third floor is a must-see a fully habitable wood-lined space running the full length of the house offering endless possibilities. The lower level includes an enviable laundry area, with potting and wrapping stations, and a large finished room with private entrance ready to be used as an office, playroom or extra bedroom.The mechanics are unbeatable, with a geothermal HVAC system on six zones, radiant heat, and steam humidifiers. All floors and walls are soundproofed, with fire sprinklers on all four floors.Blocks from the water and all Sag Harbor Village has to offer, this property and its amenities offer location, lifestyle and sanctuary. Easy walk to restaurants, library, park, marinas, jitney, Sag Harbor Cinema, Bay Street Theater, and schools. Perfect. What the seller loves about this homeThe house gets flooded with sunshine all winter and is shaded in summer. The French doors, along with a side door, can be left open all summer for a cool cross breeze. The gardens explode into bloom in stages throughout the spring, summer and fall. Four fireplaces, including one that is perfect for outdoor dining. We keep a boat at the marina just past the end of the block and, although the East Ends endless beaches are so near, the pool has made us a destination point. Great house for entertaining and guests, or just a cozy evening for two. Offices, playroom, theater, workspace there is plenty of space for everyone. Best of all, while the property is quiet and feels secluded, we are just a short walk to restaurants, shops, theater, cinema, schools, library, parks, our boat slip, the wharf and waterfront.
Show MoreShow Less


  • Interior
    5,500 Sq Ft.
  • Exterior
    .37 Acres
  • Property Type
    Single Family Home
  • Year Built
  • MLS/Listing ID
  • Days On Market


  • Central Air Conditioning
  • Fireplace(s)
  • Pool
  • Heated Pool
Show MoreShow Less


  • Air Conditioning
  • Gunite Pool
Show MoreShow Less