3 Primrose Pl

A quintessential Shelter Island summer rental. This 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offers effortless indoor-outdoor living, featuring a heated gunite pool, expansive lawn ideal for outdoor games, and multiple areas for lounging and dining al fresco. Mature landscaping creates a sense of privacy and serenity, setting the tone for easy, sun-drenched days.

Thoughtfully designed for relaxed summer living, the home features light-filled interiors that flow seamlessly to the outdoors—perfect for hosting, unwinding, and entertaining with ease. Generous gathering spaces and a well-appointed kitchen make summer meals and casual get-togethers feel effortless.

Ideally located just moments from Menhaden Lane Beach, with easy access to Shelter Island’s favorite restaurants, farm stands, and waterfront spots, this home offers the ultimate balance of convenience and escape.

A perfect setting to experience the very best of summer on Shelter Island.